Your National League Rookies of the Year.
September 10, 2007
For the AL race for Bestest Rookie, Like, Evers, check in with The Extrapolater. Those races aren’t such big old blowouts like ’round here.
Anyway, rookies, almost all of ya had to go through something like this:

And only a few of you will be celebrated today. The rest of you, well, find a place for those stockings, at least YOU won’t have to wear them anymore.
BESTEST NL ROOKIE TOSSER (and all the Brits chuckle)
by Mr Thursday
There are some who call him. . . Tim?
| PITCHER NAME | TEAM | IP | BB | SO | ERA | HR |
| Tim Lincecum | San Francisco | 133.33 | 57 | 142 | 4.05 | 12 |
I suppose arguments can be made for Kyle Kendrick (Phillies), who has a better ERA and better W-L record. I also suppose that arguments can be made for Peter Moylan (Atlanta) and Manny Corpas (Colorado) who have been excellent relievers this season. But all of these arguments fail in the face of my bloated, cross-eyed volume, not to mention in the face of 142 strikeouts in 133 IP.

He’s got a super-aggressive delivery, a great fastball, a great hook, and his future is ever-so-bright. The only knock on him, that I can see, is that he walks too many guys. As it is, if he goes his entire career with his present walk-rate, he’ll be a fine to very good pitcher. If he, like Randy Johnson and Nolan Ryan and others have done, reduces his walk rate a bit, he could start contending for Cy Young awards very, very soon.
MEANWHILE, over in the batter’s box…
BESTEST MANGLER OF OPPONENT BOX SCORES BY A MAN ON CENTRAL TIME
by Extra P.
Here are the hitting candidates:
| PLAYER NAME | TEAM | GAMES | AT BATS | RUNS | HITS | 2B | 3B | HR | RBI | SB | BB | SO | AVG | SLG |
| Ryan J. Braun | MIL | 94 | 378 | 74 | 124 | 21 | 5 | 30 | 79 | 14 | 25 | 92 | .328 | .648 |
| Hunter Pence | HOU | 91 | 387 | 52 | 125 | 28 | 8 | 14 | 56 | 9 | 21 | 77 | .323 | .545 |
I felt it necessary to put forth the top two candidates, but Ryan J. Braun is clearly the top choice. Not only is he putting up incredible numbers in every category, but he’s batting third for a team in a pennant race. Hunter Pence (batting leadoff) is having the type of rookie season that would probably be ROY-worthy in any other year, but this year he’s run up against a great young hitter in a great young lineup, and that second factor is something that the Astros just can’t match this year. They bring up the bottom while Milwaukee is battling the Cubs for the express ticket to October.

My pick - Ryan J. Braun. The Hebrew Hammer shows no signs of slowing down or buckling under the pressure of a playoff run. He crushed his 30th home run last night to put the Brewers one up on the Cubs in the NL Central. He wears my favorite number. I look forward to seeing his steely gaze at the plate for years to come.
Uh-oh. Mancrush Alert.
And don’t forget to check out the AL half of this post over at The Extrapolater, going up today!
September 10, 2007 at 1:05 pm
[...] Sep 10th, 2007 by Extra P. All season long, I have been comparing the success of MLB’s rookie hitters to the greatest first-year masher of all time - Albert Pujols. I have a pretty good idea who I would pick as offensive rookie of the year. But the fact is, there’s no guarantee that a hitter will be chosen. There are some marvelous rookie hurlers as well, and I do not have the metrics in place to gauge their success vs. the position players. So, I’ve turned to fellow Voodoo Sabermetrician TC from Mr. Thursday’s Curious Mechanism, who watches pitchers and knows how to rate them. His NL Rookie of the Year predictions, including my offensive player picks are on his site. [...]
September 10, 2007 at 6:20 pm
Braun’s the man, but Tulowitski could use a mention. Given that he’s a shortshop, is on a winning team (sort of) and plays some nice D, he might battle Pence for second on a lot of ballots.
September 11, 2007 at 1:18 pm
Adam - I’m definitely on-board with you–Tulo is a fine runner up to Braun. If were a Colorado guy, I’d look forward to having this guy around, playing SS for me for a while.
September 23, 2007 at 10:49 pm
So… I guess Tulo gets the NL gold glove @ shortstop, bats 295, sets a NL record for home runs for a rookie shortstop, but doesn’t win the ROY?
Meanwhile, Braun makes one error every 9.5 times he touches the ball. (I’ve seen Pony League players play a better third base)
May 29, 2008 at 12:34 am
[...] talking about RoY voting, I’m with the Extrapolator and had Hunter Pence of the Astros as close to Braun in the running as Tulowitzki, while not [...]